U3A Climate Study

 

Carbon Tax at European Borders Proposed

Page history last edited by Malcolm 1 mo ago

Climate heating up at EU global warming talks AFP/File â€“ Europe

BRUSSELS (AFP) – Europe, which hopes to be a model for the world at UN climate talks in Copenhagen in December, is squabbling internally over who cuts what and who pays for it.

 

Climate heating up at EU global warming talksOn paper the EU commitment is good; agreeing last December to cut greenhouse gas emissions by 20 percent overall by 2020, and by 30 percent if the rest of the world agrees in Copenhagen.

But the three months leading up to the conference aiming to prevent devastating global warming could be fraught for Europe.

A recent Franco-German initiative brandishing the threat of a carbon tax at Europe's borders for products made in countries not doing enough to tackle global warming is a case in point.

 

French President Nicolas Sarkozy and German Chancellor Angela Merkel are warning their partners of the consequences of a stalemate in Europe, because the Chinese, the Russians and the Indians are going to hard enough to convince anyway, a French strategist said.

The two leaders wrote to UN Secretary General Ban Ki-moon arguing that states that fail to back a deal at the Copenhagen talks should be held accountable.

However many others in Europe oppose this kind of heavy negotiating strategy.

"The Swedish (EU) presidency is totally against it, the European Commission is against, the Danish (hosts in Copenhagen) are against, the British and the Dutch are against, the WTO is against," on European official said.

Even in Germany there is no unanimity on the protectionist approach.

"The European Union should not mess around too much with threats," Belgian Energy Minister Paul Magnette told Le Soir newspaper, summing up the mood.

Merkel warned again Thursday that progress on the crunch UN climate summit in Copenhagen was far from adequate.

"I have to say that when I consider what still has to be achieved before Copenhagen, we cannot be happy," she said.

The other argument beginning to heat up in Europe is the question of national pollution quotas.

The European Commission took a legal hit last week when a top European court annulled its attempt to limit the amount of greenhouse gases that Estonia and Poland can let heavy industry emit.

That decision sets a precedent that could see other countries seek to raise their emission caps and upset the EU's emissions trading scheme, a key plank in Europe's plans for tackling climate change.

The court ruled, that in the cases of Estonia and Poland, the commission had overstepped its authority by rejecting the plans based only on doubts it had about how the countries collected their data.

Six other EU countries -- Bulgaria, the Czech Republic, Hungary, Latvia, Lithuania and Romania -- are pursuing similar appeals to Poland and will be encouraged by the court ruling.

Italy is also moving out of step, with Prime Minister Silvio Berlusconi sending a letter to EU Commission chief Jose Manuel Barroso seeking to renegotiate the caps on his country's carbon dioxide emissions.

So far the commission is standing firm, at least as firm as it can.

EU Environment Commissioner Stavros Dimas issued a statement Thursday seeking to put a lid on events by preventing Warsaw and Tallinn from issuing extra carbon permits to their industries while the matter was still being addressed.

He also suggested that a reevaluation was unlikely to lead to any major change in carbon allowances handed out.

The debate within Europe will be relaunched at the next meeting of EU environment ministers in Luxembourg on October 21, when the subject looks likely to overwhelm the rest of the agenda.

One of those points is the amount of financial aid poorer nations will need annually to tackle and cope with climate change, a figure somewhere between 2-15 billion euros.

Fixing that total and then dividing it up between EU nations will also not be a simple task wither.

Another of the key issues on that agenda is how to get the rest of the world to commit to more coordinated action in Copenhagen.

The world will be looking at Europe to get its green house in order first.

 

Comments (0)

You don't have permission to comment on this page.